Two Great Mutuals Are Now One!

Here for you

Giving You 125 Years Of Quality Insurance Products

Welcome to Members Mutual Insurance Association. Buena Vista Mutual and Ida Mutual Insurance Association merged on April 1, 2014. They have both been in business since 1887 and decided to combine their great principles into one dependable full-service agency to better serve their clients.

You’ll get low rates, custom packages, and individualized plans. All with the peace of mind you’re looking for.

Members Mutual Insurance Association takes pride in being a mutual business, owned by the policy holders. We rely on our customers to not only better ourselves but also better our business with you. We proudly work with 20 agencies around the area to make sure you can get the best care that you deserve.

With being a local company, that comes with many perks. Always here to answer your questions in person, or over the phone. Personal service has always been – and will always a priority to us. We specialize in farm Insurance, home insurance, and auto insurance. We can always help you figure out the right coverage for you.

With our in house claims service, we will always be there when you need us when disaster has struck. We work here as a team to make sure you get the care you need.


Call us at 712.732.6595 or fill out the form below.

"*" indicates required fields

Bill Pay

A Convenient Way to Pay

No need to panic if you stop by to make a payment after office hours. We now provide a drop box to the left of our front door entrance. Need to pay with your card? No problem! We offer a “pay your bill online” option on our website.